{ "ajzen1991:c01": { "citekey": "ajzen1991", "claim_id": "c01", "title": "The Theory of Planned Behavior", "year": 1991, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/0749-5978(91)90020-T", "claim": "TPB distinguishes attitudes toward the behaviour, subjective norms and perceived behavioural control as determinants of intention.", "page": 10, "quote_start": "The first is the attitude", "quote_end": "anticipated impediments and obstacles", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "theoretical_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Ajzen, 1991", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Ajzen" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "na", "scheme": "na", "evidence": "theoretical", "outcome": "intention" }, "attributed_study": "Ajzen (1991)", "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "ajzen1991:c02": { "citekey": "ajzen1991", "claim_id": "c02", "title": "The Theory of Planned Behavior", "year": 1991, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/0749-5978(91)90020-T", "claim": "TPB proposes that perceived behavioural control and intention jointly predict behavioural achievement.", "page": 6, "quote_start": "According to the theory of", "quote_end": "predict behavioral achievement", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "theoretical_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Ajzen, 1991", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Ajzen" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "na", "scheme": "na", "evidence": "theoretical", "outcome": "intention" }, "attributed_study": "Ajzen (1991)", "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "ajzen1991:c03": { "citekey": "ajzen1991", "claim_id": "c03", "title": "The Theory of Planned Behavior", "year": 1991, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/0749-5978(91)90020-T", "claim": "Additional TPB predictors are admissible if they explain significant additional variance in intention or behaviour beyond the existing variables.", "page": 21, "quote_start": "The theory of planned behavior is", "quote_end": "have been taken into account", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "theoretical_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Ajzen, 1991", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Ajzen" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "na", "scheme": "na", "evidence": "theoretical", "outcome": "intention" }, "attributed_study": "Ajzen (1991)", "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "ajzen1991:c04": { "citekey": "ajzen1991", "claim_id": "c04", "title": "The Theory of Planned Behavior", "year": 1991, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/0749-5978(91)90020-T", "claim": "Salient beliefs should be elicited from respondents or a pilot sample representative of the research population.", "page": 14, "quote_start": "These salient beliefs must be", "quote_end": "of the research population", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Ajzen, 1991", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Ajzen" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "na", "scheme": "na", "evidence": "theoretical", "outcome": "intention" }, "attributed_study": "Ajzen (1991)", "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "alons2017:c04": { "citekey": "alons2017", "claim_id": "c04", "title": "Environmental policy integration in the EU's common agricultural policy: greening or greenwashing?", "year": 2017, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1080/13501763.2017.1334085", "claim": "Farmers hardly had to change practices to receive greening payments, so environmental benefits were expected to be limited.", "page": 1617, "quote_start": "It is argued that farmers would hardly", "quote_end": "limited (Bureau and Mahé", "caveat": "object_mismatch", "evidence_origin": "reviewed_study", "citation_mode": "cite_original_source", "apa_cite": "Bureau and Mahé, 2015, as cited in Alons, 2017", "citation_review": true, "authors": [ "Alons" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "na", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "empirical_qual", "outcome": "other" }, "attributed_study": "Bureau and Mahé (2015)", "status": "citation review required" }, "alons2017:c08": { "citekey": "alons2017", "claim_id": "c08", "title": "Environmental policy integration in the EU's common agricultural policy: greening or greenwashing?", "year": 2017, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1080/13501763.2017.1334085", "claim": "Environmental objectives entered CAP policy-making but carry little weight relative to income and producer interests.", "page": 1618, "quote_start": "Environmental objectives have become a variable", "quote_end": "its coefficient remains small.", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Alons, 2017", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Alons" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "na", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "empirical_qual", "outcome": "other" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "ariasgiraldo2021:c02": { "citekey": "ariasgiraldo2021", "claim_id": "c02", "title": "Going Beyond Soil Conservation with the Use of Cover Crops in Mediterranean Sloping Olive Orchards", "year": 2021, "url": "https://doi.org/10.3390/agronomy11071387", "claim": "Tilled olive soil lost on average 24.7 t/ha/yr, versus 2.7 (gramineous) and 10.7 (mixed) t/ha/yr under cover crops.", "page": 13, "quote_start": "Average soil losses at the TILL treatment", "quote_end": "for CC-GRA and CC-MIX, respectively).", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Arias-Giraldo et al., 2021", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Arias-Giraldo", "Guzmán", "Montes-Borrego", "Gramaje", "Gómez", "Landa" ], "context": { "geography": "spain", "system": "olive", "scheme": "na", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "biophysical" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "bamberg2007:c01": { "citekey": "bamberg2007", "claim_id": "c01", "title": "Twenty years after Hines, Hungerford, and Tomera: A new meta-analysis of psycho-social determinants of pro-environmental behaviour", "year": 2007, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvp.2006.12.002", "claim": "Intention explained 27% of variance in self-reported pro-environmental behaviour on average.", "page": 8, "quote_start": "On average, intention explains", "quote_end": "self-reported pro-environmental behaviour", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "review_synthesis", "citation_mode": "cite_original_source", "apa_cite": "Bamberg & Möser, 2007, as cited in Bamberg & Möser, 2007", "citation_review": true, "authors": [ "Bamberg", "Möser" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "na", "scheme": "na", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": "Bamberg & Möser (2007)", "status": "citation review required" }, "bamberg2007:c02": { "citekey": "bamberg2007", "claim_id": "c02", "title": "Twenty years after Hines, Hungerford, and Tomera: A new meta-analysis of psycho-social determinants of pro-environmental behaviour", "year": 2007, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvp.2006.12.002", "claim": "After controlling for PBC, attitudes and moral norms independently predicted environmental intentions.", "page": 8, "quote_start": "After checking for the effect of PBC", "quote_end": "independent predictors of intention", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "review_synthesis", "citation_mode": "cite_original_source", "apa_cite": "Bamberg & Möser, 2007, as cited in Bamberg & Möser, 2007", "citation_review": true, "authors": [ "Bamberg", "Möser" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "na", "scheme": "na", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": "Bamberg & Möser (2007)", "status": "citation review required" }, "bamberg2007:c03": { "citekey": "bamberg2007", "claim_id": "c03", "title": "Twenty years after Hines, Hungerford, and Tomera: A new meta-analysis of psycho-social determinants of pro-environmental behaviour", "year": 2007, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvp.2006.12.002", "claim": "Reporting bias may have inflated the intention–behaviour correlation.", "page": 8, "quote_start": "Reporting bias may have resulted", "quote_end": "the intention–behaviour correlation", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Bamberg & Möser, 2007", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Bamberg", "Möser" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "na", "scheme": "na", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": "Bamberg & Möser (2007)", "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "bartkowski2021:c02": { "citekey": "bartkowski2021", "claim_id": "c02", "title": "Payments by modelled results: A novel design for agri-environmental schemes", "year": 2021, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2020.105230", "claim": "Payment certainty is the authors' most-cited specific criterion for AES design, and result-based schemes' major downside is the increasing risk they impose on farmers.", "page": 5, "quote_start": "especially payment certainty, which is related to", "quote_end": "increasing risk for suppliers", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Bartkowski et al., 2021", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Bartkowski", "Droste", "Ließ", "Sidemo-Holm", "Weller", "Brady" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "na", "scheme": "aes_results", "evidence": "theoretical", "outcome": "na" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "bartkowski2022:c02": { "citekey": "bartkowski2022", "claim_id": "c02", "title": "Typologies of European farmers: approaches, methods and research gaps", "year": 2022, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/s10113-022-01899-y", "claim": "Effective agri-environmental policy must be designed around the behavioural characteristics of farmers as its target group.", "page": 1, "quote_start": "For agri-environmental policy to be effective in fostering a transformation", "quote_end": "in mind (Brown et al. 2021; Dessart et al. 2019).", "caveat": "none", "evidence_origin": "theoretical_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Bartkowski et al., 2022", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Bartkowski", "Schüßler", "Müller" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "general_practice_adoption", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "na" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "bartkowski2023:c02": { "citekey": "bartkowski2023", "claim_id": "c02", "title": "Adoption and potential of agri-environmental schemes in Europe: Cross-regional evidence from interviews with farmers", "year": 2023, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1002/pan3.10526", "claim": "Low payments, high opportunity costs, bad fit with established practices, high bureaucratic load and the inflexibility of the schemes all affect adoption negatively.", "page": 9, "quote_start": "Particularly, low payments and high opportunity costs, bad fit with established practices", "quote_end": "inflexibility of the schemes affect adoption negatively", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Bartkowski et al., 2023", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Bartkowski", "Beckmann", "Bednář", "Biffi", "Domingo‐Marimon", "Mesaroš", "Schüßler", "Šarapatka", "Tarčak", "Václavík", "Ziv", "Wittstock" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "mixed", "scheme": "aes_practice", "evidence": "empirical_qual", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "bartkowski2023:c08": { "citekey": "bartkowski2023", "claim_id": "c08", "title": "Adoption and potential of agri-environmental schemes in Europe: Cross-regional evidence from interviews with farmers", "year": 2023, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1002/pan3.10526", "claim": "Many farmers viewed AES as compensation for practices they would implement anyway, casting doubt on additionality.", "page": 1617, "quote_start": "they are often simply viewed as a way", "quote_end": "implemented on the farm anyway", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Bartkowski et al., 2023", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Bartkowski", "Beckmann", "Bednář", "Biffi", "Domingo‐Marimon", "Mesaroš", "Schüßler", "Šarapatka", "Tarčak", "Václavík", "Ziv", "Wittstock" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "mixed", "scheme": "aes_practice", "evidence": "empirical_qual", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "canessa2023:c10": { "citekey": "canessa2023", "claim_id": "c10", "title": "Incentives, Rewards or Both in Payments for Ecosystem Services: Drawing a Link Between Farmers' Preferences and Biodiversity Levels", "year": 2023, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolecon.2023.107954", "claim": "The sample over-represented full-time farmers (73.8%) relative to the regional average (43.3%).", "page": 7, "quote_start": "share of full-time farmers", "quote_end": "average of 43.3%", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Canessa et al., 2023", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Canessa", "Venus", "Wiesmeier", "Mennig", "Sauer" ], "context": { "geography": "other_eu_ch_uk", "system": "livestock", "scheme": "aes_results", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "wta_wtp_stated" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "canessa2024:c02": { "citekey": "canessa2024", "claim_id": "c02", "title": "What matters most in determining European farmers' participation in agri-environmental measures? A systematic review of the quantitative literature", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2024.107094", "claim": "Most significant results (57% of seven models) suggest institutional trust and perceived policy stability correlate positively with AECM uptake; trust is rarely tested.", "page": 13, "quote_start": "The role of trust in influencing participation", "quote_end": "Slangen, 2008; Ducos et al., 2009).", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "review_synthesis", "citation_mode": "cite_original_source", "apa_cite": "Canessa et al., 2024", "citation_review": true, "authors": [ "Canessa", "Ait-Sidhoum", "Wunder", "Sauer" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "aes_practice", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "citation review required" }, "canessa2024:c06": { "citekey": "canessa2024", "claim_id": "c06", "title": "What matters most in determining European farmers' participation in agri-environmental measures? A systematic review of the quantitative literature", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2024.107094", "claim": "Ex-ante studies often test contract attributes, but little ex-post research shows whether design factors like monitoring, flexibility and bureaucracy affect actual decisions.", "page": 15, "quote_start": "Although many ex-ante studies assess farmers'", "quote_end": "bureaucracy) in their decisions.", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Canessa et al., 2024", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Canessa", "Ait-Sidhoum", "Wunder", "Sauer" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "aes_practice", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "canessa2024:c07": { "citekey": "canessa2024", "claim_id": "c07", "title": "What matters most in determining European farmers' participation in agri-environmental measures? A systematic review of the quantitative literature", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2024.107094", "claim": "Random utility theory and the theory of planned behaviour are the most commonly used theoretical bases in AECM adoption research.", "page": 2, "quote_start": "From a theoretical angle, the most commonly", "quote_end": "or the theory of planned behaviour.", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Canessa et al., 2024", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Canessa", "Ait-Sidhoum", "Wunder", "Sauer" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "aes_practice", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "canessa2024:c08": { "citekey": "canessa2024", "claim_id": "c08", "title": "What matters most in determining European farmers' participation in agri-environmental measures? A systematic review of the quantitative literature", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2024.107094", "claim": "Aligning measures with farmers' needs raises adoption, but excessive alignment risks self-selection of baseline-complying farmers and likely jeopardises additionality.", "page": 1, "quote_start": "Enhancing the alignment of the measures with", "quote_end": "likely jeopardizes AECM additionality.", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Canessa et al., 2024", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Canessa", "Ait-Sidhoum", "Wunder", "Sauer" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "aes_practice", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "carmonatorres2023:c03": { "citekey": "carmonatorres2023", "claim_id": "c03", "title": "Abandonment factors and alternatives in sloping olive growing: The case of Andalusia, Spain", "year": 2023, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2023.106836", "claim": "Growers with abandoned olive fields more often attached low importance to environmental, health and landscape goals than growers with fields in production.", "page": 6, "quote_start": "They also attach low importance", "quote_end": "heritage (33.3% vs. 0.0%).", "caveat": "object_mismatch", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Carmona-Torres et al., 2023", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Carmona-Torres", "Parra-López", "Sayadi", "Reina-Usuga" ], "context": { "geography": "andalusia", "system": "olive", "scheme": "general_practice_adoption", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "carmonatorres2023:c09": { "citekey": "carmonatorres2023", "claim_id": "c09", "title": "Abandonment factors and alternatives in sloping olive growing: The case of Andalusia, Spain", "year": 2023, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2023.106836", "claim": "Knowledge transfer is needed through traditional sources (agricultural associations) and institutional sources (universities, public research bodies, technology centres).", "page": 10, "quote_start": "Knowledge transfer is needed through traditional sources such as agricultural associations", "quote_end": "because of their public service vocation", "caveat": "object_mismatch", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Carmona-Torres et al., 2023", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Carmona-Torres", "Parra-López", "Sayadi", "Reina-Usuga" ], "context": { "geography": "andalusia", "system": "olive", "scheme": "general_practice_adoption", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "carmonatorres2023:c10": { "citekey": "carmonatorres2023", "claim_id": "c10", "title": "Abandonment factors and alternatives in sloping olive growing: The case of Andalusia, Spain", "year": 2023, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2023.106836", "claim": "Long-term continuity is not assured on 88 per cent of Andalusian mountain olive farms, which face a high risk of abandonment.", "page": 1, "quote_start": "high risk of abandonment of mountain olive groves", "quote_end": "not assured in 88% of the farms", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "reviewed_study", "citation_mode": "cite_original_source", "apa_cite": "Villanueva et al., 2018, as cited in Carmona-Torres et al., 2023", "citation_review": true, "authors": [ "Carmona-Torres", "Parra-López", "Sayadi", "Reina-Usuga" ], "context": { "geography": "andalusia", "system": "olive", "scheme": "general_practice_adoption", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": "Villanueva et al. (2018)", "status": "citation review required" }, "cerda2022:c01": { "citekey": "cerda2022", "claim_id": "c01", "title": "Examining the Effectiveness of Catch Crops as a Nature-Based Solution to Mitigate Surface Soil and Water Losses as an Environmental Regional Concern", "year": 2021, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/s41748-021-00284-9", "claim": "Almost all surveyed citrus farmers (95%) regarded catch crops as 'dirty' management, and very few (5.5%) believed they improve soil quality.", "page": 36, "quote_start": "A significant number of farmers (95%) believed", "quote_end": "the soil quality (5.5%).", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Cerdà et al., 2021", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Cerdà", "Franch-Pardo", "Novara", "Sannigrahi", "Rodrigo-Comino" ], "context": { "geography": "spain", "system": "other_permanent", "scheme": "general_practice_adoption", "evidence": "mixed", "outcome": "attitude_only" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "chapman2022:c06": { "citekey": "chapman2022", "claim_id": "c06", "title": "Social-ecological feedbacks drive tipping points in farming system diversification", "year": 2022, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.oneear.2022.02.007", "claim": "Ecological responses to diversification practices (hedgerows, building organic matter) happen slowly, often taking years to return benefits, which can exceed investment planning timeframes.", "page": 287, "quote_start": "ecological responses to management actions in these systems (such as planting hedgerows or building up organic matter in soils) happen slowly", "quote_end": "often taking years to return ecological and/or financial benefits", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Chapman et al., 2022", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Chapman", "Wiltshire", "Baur", "Bowles", "Carlisle", "Castillo", "Esquivel", "Gennet", "Iles", "Karp", "Kremen", "Liebert", "Olimpi", "Ory", "Ryan", "Sciligo", "Thompson", "Waterhouse", "Boettiger" ], "context": { "geography": "non_eu", "system": "mixed", "scheme": "general_practice_adoption", "evidence": "modelling", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "colombo2018:c01": { "citekey": "colombo2018", "claim_id": "c01", "title": "Result-oriented Agri-Environmental Climate Schemes as a means of promoting climate change mitigation in olive growing", "year": 2018, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0030727018770931", "claim": "Andalusia alone accounts for 32% of the EU's olive-growing area and 60% of Spain's.", "page": 141, "quote_start": "Approximately 4.2 million hectares of olives", "quote_end": "world leader in olive production.", "caveat": "none", "evidence_origin": "official_statistics", "citation_mode": "cite_original_source", "apa_cite": "Eurostat, 2015, as cited in Colombo & Rocamora-Montiel, 2018", "citation_review": true, "authors": [ "Colombo", "Rocamora-Montiel" ], "context": { "geography": "andalusia", "system": "olive", "scheme": "aes_results", "evidence": "theoretical", "outcome": "na" }, "attributed_study": "Eurostat (2015)", "status": "citation review required" }, "colombo2024:c01": { "citekey": "colombo2024", "claim_id": "c01", "title": "Analysis of the environmental and economic performance of common agricultural policy eco-schemes in soil organic carbon sequestration", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolecon.2024.108183", "claim": "Cover crops are present on 73% of Andalusian olive-grove area according to farmers' CAP declarations, pooling all cover-crop variants.", "page": 5, "quote_start": "The presence of cover crops is", "quote_end": "including cover crops", "caveat": "object_mismatch", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Colombo et al., 2024", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Colombo", "Castro-Rodríguez", "Peréz-Pérez", "Almagro" ], "context": { "geography": "andalusia", "system": "olive", "scheme": "eco_scheme", "evidence": "modelling", "outcome": "biophysical" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "colombo2024:c03": { "citekey": "colombo2024", "claim_id": "c03", "title": "Analysis of the environmental and economic performance of common agricultural policy eco-schemes in soil organic carbon sequestration", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolecon.2024.108183", "claim": "Only 57% of cover-cropped Andalusian olive area would currently meet eco-scheme requirements; elsewhere covers are controlled by tillage or herbicides.", "page": 6, "quote_start": "However, only the 57% of", "quote_end": "used to control cover crops.", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Colombo et al., 2024", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Colombo", "Castro-Rodríguez", "Peréz-Pérez", "Almagro" ], "context": { "geography": "andalusia", "system": "olive", "scheme": "eco_scheme", "evidence": "modelling", "outcome": "biophysical" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "colombo2024:c06": { "citekey": "colombo2024", "claim_id": "c06", "title": "Analysis of the environmental and economic performance of common agricultural policy eco-schemes in soil organic carbon sequestration", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolecon.2024.108183", "claim": "Under projected uptake, budget-constrained average eco-scheme payments per olive hectare would fall well below the scheduled 136.7 €/ha.", "page": 9, "quote_start": "According to the adoption rates considered", "quote_end": "plan of CAP for Spain", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Colombo et al., 2024", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Colombo", "Castro-Rodríguez", "Peréz-Pérez", "Almagro" ], "context": { "geography": "andalusia", "system": "olive", "scheme": "eco_scheme", "evidence": "modelling", "outcome": "biophysical" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "cuadroscasanova2023:c03": { "citekey": "cuadroscasanova2023", "claim_id": "c03", "title": "Opportunities and challenges for Common Agricultural Policy reform to support the European Green Deal", "year": 2023, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/cobi.14052", "claim": "Authors argue that enhanced conditionality sets lower environmental protection than the previous obligatory greening requirements.", "page": 10, "quote_start": "The new measures added by", "quote_end": "greening requirements under cross-compliance.", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Cuadros‐Casanova et al., 2023", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Cuadros‐Casanova", "Cristiano", "Biancolini", "Cimatti", "Sessa", "Mendez Angarita", "Dragonetti", "Pacifici", "Rondinini", "Di Marco" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "review_narrative", "outcome": "other" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "cuadroscasanova2023:c04": { "citekey": "cuadroscasanova2023", "claim_id": "c04", "title": "Opportunities and challenges for Common Agricultural Policy reform to support the European Green Deal", "year": 2023, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/cobi.14052", "claim": "Some previously compulsory measures are now addressed only through voluntary eco-schemes, delegating responsibility to member states.", "page": 10, "quote_start": "Also, some of the measures previously implemented as compulsory will now only be addressed in the voluntary ecoschemes", "quote_end": "delegating responsibility to individual member states", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Cuadros‐Casanova et al., 2023", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Cuadros‐Casanova", "Cristiano", "Biancolini", "Cimatti", "Sessa", "Mendez Angarita", "Dragonetti", "Pacifici", "Rondinini", "Di Marco" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "review_narrative", "outcome": "other" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "dessart2019:c01": { "citekey": "dessart2019", "claim_id": "c01", "title": "Behavioural factors affecting the adoption of sustainable farming practices: a policy-oriented review", "year": 2019, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1093/erae/jbz019", "claim": "Within farming communities intensive, productive agriculture is still often the symbol of 'good farming', with competition based on yield not environmental performance.", "page": 437, "quote_start": "Whereas the need for public recognition from society", "quote_end": "Sutherland and Darnhofer, 2012).", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "review_synthesis", "citation_mode": "cite_original_source", "apa_cite": "Dessart et al., 2019", "citation_review": true, "authors": [ "Dessart", "Barreiro-Hurlé", "van Bavel" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "general_practice_adoption", "evidence": "review_narrative", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "citation review required" }, "dessart2019:c02": { "citekey": "dessart2019", "claim_id": "c02", "title": "Behavioural factors affecting the adoption of sustainable farming practices: a policy-oriented review", "year": 2019, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1093/erae/jbz019", "claim": "In a five-country EU survey most farmers participating in paid agri-environmental schemes were motivated by economic gains.", "page": 430, "quote_start": "A survey carried out in five EU Member States", "quote_end": "economic gains (Pavlis et al., 2016).", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "reviewed_study", "citation_mode": "cite_original_source", "apa_cite": "Pavlis et al., 2016, as cited in Dessart et al., 2019", "citation_review": true, "authors": [ "Dessart", "Barreiro-Hurlé", "van Bavel" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "general_practice_adoption", "evidence": "review_narrative", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": "Pavlis et al. (2016)", "status": "citation review required" }, "dessart2019:c09": { "citekey": "dessart2019", "claim_id": "c09", "title": "Behavioural factors affecting the adoption of sustainable farming practices: a policy-oriented review", "year": 2019, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1093/erae/jbz019", "claim": "The CAP impact assessment modelled eco-scheme enrolment on purely economic drivers; the authors argue behavioural factors imply lower adoption.", "page": 450, "quote_start": "For instance, in the current impact assessment", "quote_end": "may not be as high as expected.", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Dessart et al., 2019", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Dessart", "Barreiro-Hurlé", "van Bavel" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "general_practice_adoption", "evidence": "review_narrative", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "dessart2019:c10": { "citekey": "dessart2019", "claim_id": "c10", "title": "Behavioural factors affecting the adoption of sustainable farming practices: a policy-oriented review", "year": 2019, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1093/erae/jbz019", "claim": "It is unclear how behavioural factors operate when farmers face a mix of mandatory and voluntary opt-in schemes, as under the new CAP.", "page": 454, "quote_start": "Most behavioural research focuses on farmers' voluntary", "quote_end": "voluntary (i.e. opt-in) schemes.", "caveat": "none", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Dessart et al., 2019", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Dessart", "Barreiro-Hurlé", "van Bavel" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "general_practice_adoption", "evidence": "review_narrative", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "devries2019:c03": { "citekey": "devries2019", "claim_id": "c03", "title": "Trusting the People and the System. The Interrelation Between Interpersonal and Institutional Trust in Collective Action for Agri-Environmental Management", "year": 2019, "url": "https://doi.org/10.3390/su11247022", "claim": "Practical help reduced initial uncertainty, improved attitudes toward the new policy and built trust through a shared positive history.", "page": 10, "quote_start": "The practical and positive experiences took away", "quote_end": "started to take shape.", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "de Vries et al., 2019", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "de Vries", "van der Zee", "Beunen", "Kat", "Feindt" ], "context": { "geography": "other_eu_ch_uk", "system": "mixed", "scheme": "aes_collective", "evidence": "empirical_qual", "outcome": "other" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "devries2019:c05": { "citekey": "devries2019", "claim_id": "c05", "title": "Trusting the People and the System. The Interrelation Between Interpersonal and Institutional Trust in Collective Action for Agri-Environmental Management", "year": 2019, "url": "https://doi.org/10.3390/su11247022", "claim": "Auditing was experienced as an expression of mistrust, offsetting the trust signal created by greater farmer responsibilities.", "page": 10, "quote_start": "Therefore, although the new model gave greater responsibilities", "quote_end": "the farmers and the collective.", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "de Vries et al., 2019", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "de Vries", "van der Zee", "Beunen", "Kat", "Feindt" ], "context": { "geography": "other_eu_ch_uk", "system": "mixed", "scheme": "aes_collective", "evidence": "empirical_qual", "outcome": "other" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "devries2019:c06": { "citekey": "devries2019", "claim_id": "c06", "title": "Trusting the People and the System. The Interrelation Between Interpersonal and Institutional Trust in Collective Action for Agri-Environmental Management", "year": 2019, "url": "https://doi.org/10.3390/su11247022", "claim": "Occasional inconsistencies revived memories of prior mistreatment and reduced trust in the new policy despite generally positive experiences.", "page": 11, "quote_start": "While farmers and employees of AND", "quote_end": "policy and the collective.", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "de Vries et al., 2019", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "de Vries", "van der Zee", "Beunen", "Kat", "Feindt" ], "context": { "geography": "other_eu_ch_uk", "system": "mixed", "scheme": "aes_collective", "evidence": "empirical_qual", "outcome": "other" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "devries2019:c09": { "citekey": "devries2019", "claim_id": "c09", "title": "Trusting the People and the System. The Interrelation Between Interpersonal and Institutional Trust in Collective Action for Agri-Environmental Management", "year": 2019, "url": "https://doi.org/10.3390/su11247022", "claim": "As the new system performed well, interpersonal trust became less important and a generalised trust in the policy emerged, especially among non-farmers.", "page": 11, "quote_start": "Interviewees, especially non-farmers, indicated that over time", "quote_end": "policy started to emerge.", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "de Vries et al., 2019", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "de Vries", "van der Zee", "Beunen", "Kat", "Feindt" ], "context": { "geography": "other_eu_ch_uk", "system": "mixed", "scheme": "aes_collective", "evidence": "empirical_qual", "outcome": "other" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "duranzuazo2020:c02": { "citekey": "duranzuazo2020", "claim_id": "c02", "title": "Benefits of organic olive rainfed systems to control soil erosion and runoff and improve soil health restoration", "year": 2020, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/s13593-020-00644-1", "claim": "Mean olive yield did not differ significantly between organic, conservation, integrated and conventional soil management over four seasons.", "page": 1, "quote_start": "The mean olive yield was not significantly", "quote_end": "conservation, and conventional, respectively.", "caveat": "object_mismatch", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Zuazo et al., 2020", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Zuazo", "Rodríguez", "García-Tejero", "Ruiz", "Tavira" ], "context": { "geography": "andalusia", "system": "olive", "scheme": "na", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "biophysical" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "epanchinniell2022:c01": { "citekey": "epanchinniell2022", "claim_id": "c01", "title": "Private land conservation decision-making: An integrative social science model", "year": 2022, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2021.113961", "claim": "The model explains behavioural heterogeneity through interactions among decision context, behaviour attributes and decision-maker attributes.", "page": 1, "quote_start": "The model highlights how heterogeneity", "quote_end": "attributes of the decision-maker", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "theoretical_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Epanchin-Niell et al., 2022", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Epanchin-Niell", "Jackson-Smith", "Wilson", "Ashenfarb", "Dayer", "Hillis", "Iacona", "Markowitz", "Marquart-Pyatt", "Treakle" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "theoretical", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": "Epanchin-Niell et al. (2022)", "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "esyrce2015and:c01": { "citekey": "esyrce2015and", "claim_id": "c01", "title": "Junta de Andalucía / AGAPA, Análisis de las plantaciones de olivar en Andalucía. Año 2015 (ESYRCE)", "year": null, "url": "", "claim": "39.7% of Andalusian olive (622,650 ha) already had a spontaneous cover crop in 2015, before the eco-scheme existed.", "page": 8, "quote_start": "CUBIERTA VEGETAL ESPONTÁNEA 622.650 39,7%", "quote_end": "CUBIERTA INERTE 19.900 1,3%", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "official_statistics", "citation_mode": "cite_original_source", "apa_cite": "ESYRCE, None", "citation_review": true, "authors": [ "ESYRCE" ], "context": { "geography": "spain", "system": "olive", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "statistics", "outcome": "other" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "citation review required" }, "francaviglia2023:c05": { "citekey": "francaviglia2023", "claim_id": "c05", "title": "Conservation Agriculture and Soil Organic Carbon: Principles, Processes, Practices and Policy Options", "year": 2023, "url": "https://doi.org/10.3390/soilsystems7010017", "claim": "Avoiding bare soil in sensitive periods and crop rotation are mandatory conditionality requirements in the new CAP, overlapping with conservation agriculture practices.", "page": 22, "quote_start": "Importantly, the avoidance of bare soils in most sensitive periods", "quote_end": "reduced tillage, crop diversification, and cover crops).", "caveat": "none", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Francaviglia et al., 2023", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Francaviglia", "Almagro", "Vicente-Vicente" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "general_practice_adoption", "evidence": "review_narrative", "outcome": "biophysical" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "fritsche2018:c01": { "citekey": "fritsche2018", "claim_id": "c01", "title": "A Social Identity Model of Pro-Environmental Action (SIMPEA)", "year": 2018, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1037/rev0000090", "claim": "SIMPEA proposes that identification, ingroup norms and goals, and collective efficacy determine environmental appraisals and action.", "page": 1, "quote_start": "Specifically, we propose that ingroup", "quote_end": "public sphere environmental action", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "theoretical_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Fritsche et al., 2018", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Fritsche", "Barth", "Jugert", "Masson", "Reese" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "na", "scheme": "na", "evidence": "theoretical", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": "Fritsche et al. (2018)", "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "gatto2019:c06": { "citekey": "gatto2019", "claim_id": "c06", "title": "Analysing the role of factors affecting farmers' decisions to continue with agri-environmental schemes from a temporal perspective", "year": 2019, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envsci.2018.12.001", "claim": "Trust in the regional authority designing and managing AES positively affects continuation, while technical advice received from public institutions has a negative effect.", "page": 4, "quote_start": "trust in the regional authorities in charge of design and management", "quote_end": "the effect on duration of technical advice", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Gatto et al., 2019", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Gatto", "Mozzato", "Defrancesco" ], "context": { "geography": "other_eu_ch_uk", "system": "mixed", "scheme": "aes_practice", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "gatto2019:c09": { "citekey": "gatto2019", "claim_id": "c09", "title": "Analysing the role of factors affecting farmers' decisions to continue with agri-environmental schemes from a temporal perspective", "year": 2019, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envsci.2018.12.001", "claim": "Social pressure and neighbouring-farmer influence were the weakest predictors of continuation in the models tested.", "page": 4, "quote_start": "both the farmers' environmentally friendly attitude", "quote_end": "are not significant", "caveat": "object_mismatch", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Gatto et al., 2019", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Gatto", "Mozzato", "Defrancesco" ], "context": { "geography": "other_eu_ch_uk", "system": "mixed", "scheme": "aes_practice", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "gomez2014:c04": { "citekey": "gomez2014", "claim_id": "c04", "title": "Olive Cultivation, its Impact on Soil Erosion and its Progression into Yield Impacts in Southern Spain in the Past as a Key to a Future of Increasing Climate Uncertainty", "year": 2014, "url": "https://doi.org/10.3390/agriculture4020170", "claim": "Cover-crop growth must be controlled in spring to prevent soil-water competition, since Andalusian olives are mainly rainfed or deficit-irrigated.", "page": 180, "quote_start": "In the latter case, control of the", "quote_end": "are under deficit irrigation.", "caveat": "object_mismatch", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Gómez et al., 2014", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Gómez", "Infante-Amate", "De Molina", "Vanwalleghem", "Taguas", "Lorite" ], "context": { "geography": "andalusia", "system": "olive", "scheme": "general_practice_adoption", "evidence": "review_narrative", "outcome": "biophysical" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "gomez2018:c07": { "citekey": "gomez2018", "claim_id": "c07", "title": "Soil erosion control, plant diversity, and arthropod communities under heterogeneous cover crops in an olive orchard", "year": 2017, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-016-8339-9", "claim": "Seeded cover crops risk costly establishment failure from intense storms or autumn–winter drought, which are periodic in Mediterranean climate.", "page": 983, "quote_start": "Second, it spreads the risk of", "quote_end": "features in Mediterranean climate.", "caveat": "object_mismatch", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Gómez et al., 2017", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Gómez", "Campos", "Guzmán", "Castillo-Llanque", "Vanwalleghem", "Lora", "Giráldez" ], "context": { "geography": "andalusia", "system": "olive", "scheme": "na", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "biophysical" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "gomez2026:c05": { "citekey": "gomez2026", "claim_id": "c05", "title": "Desertification in Olive Orchards: A Complex Challenge for a Diverse Agricultural System", "year": 2026, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-032-09648-7_15", "claim": "Erosion control by vegetation cover depends on correct implementation, and studies indicate very high variability in cover quality between farms.", "page": 147, "quote_start": "The first of them is that the effect", "quote_end": "between farms, see Fig. 15.6.", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "review_synthesis", "citation_mode": "cite_original_source", "apa_cite": "Alfonso Gómez, 2026", "citation_review": true, "authors": [ "Alfonso Gómez" ], "context": { "geography": "spain", "system": "olive", "scheme": "na", "evidence": "review_narrative", "outcome": "biophysical" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "citation review required" }, "granadodiaz2024:c08": { "citekey": "granadodiaz2024", "claim_id": "c08", "title": "Farmers' attitudes toward the use of digital technologies in the context of agri-environmental policies", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agsy.2024.104129", "claim": "Implementing digitally-based results-based schemes would require a novel governance organisation that reduces information asymmetry and reinforces mutual trust.", "page": 9, "quote_start": "The implementation of such a system", "quote_end": "mutual trust is reinforced.", "caveat": "object_mismatch", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Granado-Díaz et al., 2024", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Granado-Díaz", "Colombo", "Romero-Varo", "Villanueva" ], "context": { "geography": "andalusia", "system": "multi", "scheme": "aes_results", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "attitude_only" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "gutschow2021:c02": { "citekey": "gutschow2021", "claim_id": "c02", "title": "Farmers’ action space to adopt sustainable practices: a study of arable farming in Saxony", "year": 2021, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/s10113-021-01848-1", "claim": "Limited regulatory predictability, coherence and flexibility restricted farmers’ perceived action space.", "page": 1, "quote_start": "In addition, limited regulatory predictability", "quote_end": "in their action space", "caveat": "object_mismatch", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Gütschow et al., 2021", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Gütschow", "Bartkowski", "Felipe-Lucia" ], "context": { "geography": "other_eu_ch_uk", "system": "arable", "scheme": "general_practice_adoption", "evidence": "mixed", "outcome": "other" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "gutschow2021:c04": { "citekey": "gutschow2021", "claim_id": "c04", "title": "Farmers’ action space to adopt sustainable practices: a study of arable farming in Saxony", "year": 2021, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/s10113-021-01848-1", "claim": "Action-space analysis can explain barriers but cannot alone predict behaviour without considering individual motivations.", "page": 13, "quote_start": "While the action space perspective", "quote_end": "engage in particular behaviors", "caveat": "object_mismatch", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Gütschow et al., 2021", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Gütschow", "Bartkowski", "Felipe-Lucia" ], "context": { "geography": "other_eu_ch_uk", "system": "arable", "scheme": "general_practice_adoption", "evidence": "mixed", "outcome": "other" }, "attributed_study": "Gütschow et al. (2021)", "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "han2023:c01": { "citekey": "han2023", "claim_id": "c01", "title": "An adoption spectrum for sustainable agriculture practices: A new framework applied to cover crop adoption", "year": 2023, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agsy.2023.103771", "claim": "Self-efficacy about cover-crop management sharply increased the odds of being an early adopter rather than a non-adopter.", "page": 7, "quote_start": "However, as compared to non-adopters, early", "quote_end": "= 1.0005, p < 0.05).", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Han & Niles, 2023", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Han", "Niles" ], "context": { "geography": "non_eu", "system": "arable", "scheme": "general_practice_adoption", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "han2023:c02": { "citekey": "han2023", "claim_id": "c02", "title": "An adoption spectrum for sustainable agriculture practices: A new framework applied to cover crop adoption", "year": 2023, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agsy.2023.103771", "claim": "Communication about cover crops through social networks was among the strongest predictors of adoption versus non-adoption and of persistence versus dis-adoption.", "page": 10, "quote_start": "Indeed, we find that both self-efficacy", "quote_end": "previous adopters from early adopters.", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Han & Niles, 2023", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Han", "Niles" ], "context": { "geography": "non_eu", "system": "arable", "scheme": "general_practice_adoption", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "han2023:c08": { "citekey": "han2023", "claim_id": "c08", "title": "An adoption spectrum for sustainable agriculture practices: A new framework applied to cover crop adoption", "year": 2023, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agsy.2023.103771", "claim": "The survey likely over-represented adopters and innovators because of nonresponse bias relative to national adoption data.", "page": 11, "quote_start": "As we presented earlier, our respondents include", "quote_end": "non and previous adopters.", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Han & Niles, 2023", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Han", "Niles" ], "context": { "geography": "non_eu", "system": "arable", "scheme": "general_practice_adoption", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "homet2024:c08": { "citekey": "homet2024", "claim_id": "c08", "title": "Viticulture and the European Union's Common Agricultural Policy (CAP): Historical overview, current situation and future perspective", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1002/sae2.12099", "claim": "Eco-schemes reward farms that implement climate- and environment-friendly practices through voluntary annual commitments, taking the form of an annual payment per eligible hectare.", "page": 6, "quote_start": "Eco-schemes reward farms that implement climate- and environment-friendly agricultural practices through voluntary annual commitments", "quote_end": "an annual payment per eligible hectare", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Homet et al., 2024", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Homet", "Gallardo‐Reina", "Aguiar", "Liberal", "Casimiro‐Soriguer", "Ochoa‐Hueso" ], "context": { "geography": "spain", "system": "other_permanent", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "review_narrative", "outcome": "na" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "janssen2026:c02": { "citekey": "janssen2026", "claim_id": "c02", "title": "The social-ecological learning framework: perception, action, and learning in a changing world", "year": 2026, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2026.103159", "claim": "The proposed framework treats social and ecological relations as jointly shaping learning.", "page": 1, "quote_start": "This lens highlights how human–human", "quote_end": "situated, and vice versa", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "theoretical_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Janssen et al., 2026", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Janssen", "Gorris", "Pahl-Wostl", "Schwarz" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "na", "scheme": "na", "evidence": "theoretical", "outcome": "other" }, "attributed_study": "Janssen et al. (2026)", "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "kathage2022:c02": { "citekey": "kathage2022", "claim_id": "c02", "title": "How much is policy driving the adoption of cover crops? Evidence from four EU regions", "year": 2022, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2022.106016", "claim": "Environmental considerations were not important drivers of cover-crop adoption in the four surveyed regions.", "page": 10, "quote_start": "Environmental considerations were not found", "quote_end": "important drivers of adoption.", "caveat": "object_mismatch", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Kathage et al., 2022", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Kathage", "Smit", "Janssens", "Haagsma", "Adrados" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "arable", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "kathage2022:c10": { "citekey": "kathage2022", "claim_id": "c10", "title": "How much is policy driving the adoption of cover crops? Evidence from four EU regions", "year": 2022, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2022.106016", "claim": "Stated responsiveness and WTA results may suffer from hypothetical bias and strategic over-reporting of required subsidies.", "page": 10, "quote_start": "It should be noted that the results about responsiveness", "quote_end": "report an inflated WTA).", "caveat": "outcome_type", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Kathage et al., 2022", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Kathage", "Smit", "Janssens", "Haagsma", "Adrados" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "arable", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "kelemen2023:c06": { "citekey": "kelemen2023", "claim_id": "c06", "title": "The prospects of innovative agri-environmental contracts in the European policy context: Results from a Delphi study", "year": 2023, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2023.106706", "claim": "Experts preferred top-up payments or force-majeure budgets to address risks of failing to deliver contracted results.", "page": 7, "quote_start": "Emerging risks and uncertainties were", "quote_end": "provide the expected results", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Kelemen et al., 2023", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Kelemen", "Megyesi", "Matzdorf", "Andersen", "van Bussel", "Dumortier", "Dutilly", "García-Llorente", "Hamon", "LePage", "Moruzzo", "Prager", "Riccioli", "Yacamán-Ochoa" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "mixed", "outcome": "attitude_only" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "kuhfuss2015:c04": { "citekey": "kuhfuss2015", "claim_id": "c04", "title": "Nudging farmers to enrol land into agri-environmental schemes: the virtues of a collective bonus", "year": 2015, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1093/erae/jbv031", "claim": "Free technical and administrative assistance in the contract raised winegrowers' stated probability of participating.", "page": 13, "quote_start": "Introducing a bonus or free technical", "quote_end": "participate in the AES.", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Kuhfuss et al., 2015", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Kuhfuss", "Préget", "Thoyer", "Hanley" ], "context": { "geography": "med_eu", "system": "other_permanent", "scheme": "aes_collective", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "wta_wtp_stated" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "kuhfuss2015:c06": { "citekey": "kuhfuss2015", "claim_id": "c06", "title": "Nudging farmers to enrol land into agri-environmental schemes: the virtues of a collective bonus", "year": 2015, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1093/erae/jbv031", "claim": "Without flexibility to use herbicides in problem areas, farmers were less likely to enrol their whole vineyard.", "page": 16, "quote_start": "Furthermore, we can see that if the", "quote_end": "their whole vineyard area.", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Kuhfuss et al., 2015", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Kuhfuss", "Préget", "Thoyer", "Hanley" ], "context": { "geography": "med_eu", "system": "other_permanent", "scheme": "aes_collective", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "wta_wtp_stated" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "kuhfuss2015:c07": { "citekey": "kuhfuss2015", "claim_id": "c07", "title": "Nudging farmers to enrol land into agri-environmental schemes: the virtues of a collective bonus", "year": 2015, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1093/erae/jbv031", "claim": "The online sample under-represented women, older, less-educated winegrowers and smaller cooperative-member farms relative to the census.", "page": 12, "quote_start": "Our sample is slightly biased because of", "quote_end": "are under-represented.", "caveat": "none", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Kuhfuss et al., 2015", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Kuhfuss", "Préget", "Thoyer", "Hanley" ], "context": { "geography": "med_eu", "system": "other_permanent", "scheme": "aes_collective", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "wta_wtp_stated" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "kuhfuss2015:c09": { "citekey": "kuhfuss2015", "claim_id": "c09", "title": "Nudging farmers to enrol land into agri-environmental schemes: the virtues of a collective bonus", "year": 2015, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1093/erae/jbv031", "claim": "Simulated adoption rose more with a conditional collective bonus than with an equivalent unconditional payment increase.", "page": 18, "quote_start": "On average, farmers have a probability of", "quote_end": "average adoption rate of 41%", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Kuhfuss et al., 2015", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Kuhfuss", "Préget", "Thoyer", "Hanley" ], "context": { "geography": "med_eu", "system": "other_permanent", "scheme": "aes_collective", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "wta_wtp_stated" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "kuhfuss2016:c02": { "citekey": "kuhfuss2016", "claim_id": "c02", "title": "Nudges, social norms and permanence in agri-environmental schemes", "year": 2016, "url": "https://doi.org/10.3368/le.92.4.641", "claim": "Information that most peers intend to continue more than doubled the odds of stating intention to maintain AES practices.", "page": 17, "quote_start": "the odds ratios show that the odds", "quote_end": "in the control group (Table 3).", "caveat": "object_mismatch", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Kuhfuss et al., 2016", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Kuhfuss", "Préget", "Thoyer", "Hanley", "Coent", "Désolé" ], "context": { "geography": "other_eu_ch_uk", "system": "mixed", "scheme": "aes_practice", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "intention" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "kuhfuss2016:c03": { "citekey": "kuhfuss2016", "claim_id": "c03", "title": "Nudges, social norms and permanence in agri-environmental schemes", "year": 2016, "url": "https://doi.org/10.3368/le.92.4.641", "claim": "Positive versus negative framing of the same norm information had no significant effect on stated intention.", "page": 17, "quote_start": "However, a test of equality of parameters", "quote_end": "no significant effect here.", "caveat": "object_mismatch", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Kuhfuss et al., 2016", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Kuhfuss", "Préget", "Thoyer", "Hanley", "Coent", "Désolé" ], "context": { "geography": "other_eu_ch_uk", "system": "mixed", "scheme": "aes_practice", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "intention" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "kuhfuss2016:c06": { "citekey": "kuhfuss2016", "claim_id": "c06", "title": "Nudges, social norms and permanence in agri-environmental schemes", "year": 2016, "url": "https://doi.org/10.3368/le.92.4.641", "claim": "About two-thirds of AES participants said they joined partly because their practices already matched the requirements.", "page": 13, "quote_start": "Some 68% of the farmers of our", "quote_end": "line with AES requirements.", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Kuhfuss et al., 2016", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Kuhfuss", "Préget", "Thoyer", "Hanley", "Coent", "Désolé" ], "context": { "geography": "other_eu_ch_uk", "system": "mixed", "scheme": "aes_practice", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "intention" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "kuhfuss2016:c08": { "citekey": "kuhfuss2016", "claim_id": "c08", "title": "Nudges, social norms and permanence in agri-environmental schemes", "year": 2016, "url": "https://doi.org/10.3368/le.92.4.641", "claim": "Reliance on stated intentions is a limitation because farmers may strategically over- or under-state intentions.", "page": 20, "quote_start": "One potential limit of this paper", "quote_end": "will actually maintain them.", "caveat": "none", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Kuhfuss et al., 2016", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Kuhfuss", "Préget", "Thoyer", "Hanley", "Coent", "Désolé" ], "context": { "geography": "other_eu_ch_uk", "system": "mixed", "scheme": "aes_practice", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "intention" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "lopezbernal2023:c01": { "citekey": "lopezbernal2023", "claim_id": "c01", "title": "Modelling the impacts of cover crop management strategies on the water use, carbon exchange and yield of olive orchards", "year": 2022, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/s11676-022-01570-6", "claim": "Spanish CAP implementation promotes cover-crop adoption in olive orchards through mandatory requirements rather than voluntary incentives.", "page": 284, "quote_start": "In the light of some of these", "quote_end": "requirements in olive orchards.", "caveat": "object_mismatch", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "López-Bernal et al., 2022", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "López-Bernal", "García-Tejera", "Testi", "Villalobos" ], "context": { "geography": "andalusia", "system": "olive", "scheme": "na", "evidence": "modelling", "outcome": "biophysical" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "mack2019:c02": { "citekey": "mack2019", "claim_id": "c02", "title": "Determinants of the perceived administrative transaction costs caused by the uptake of an agri-environmental program", "year": 2019, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1080/09640568.2018.1515311", "claim": "Knowledge of policy regulations significantly reduced farmers' perceived administrative workload of the programme.", "page": 1815, "quote_start": "We verified that knowledge of policy", "quote_end": "[variable Policy information].", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Mack et al., 2019", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Mack", "Kohler", "Heitkämper", "El-Benni" ], "context": { "geography": "other_eu_ch_uk", "system": "livestock", "scheme": "non_eu_program", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "attitude_only" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "mack2019:c05": { "citekey": "mack2019", "claim_id": "c05", "title": "Determinants of the perceived administrative transaction costs caused by the uptake of an agri-environmental program", "year": 2019, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1080/09640568.2018.1515311", "claim": "Farmers who had experienced enforcement measures rated the administrative workload significantly higher, with a majority rating it high.", "page": 1814, "quote_start": "Figure 1, Enforcements, indicates that", "quote_end": "rates the workload to be high.", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Mack et al., 2019", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Mack", "Kohler", "Heitkämper", "El-Benni" ], "context": { "geography": "other_eu_ch_uk", "system": "livestock", "scheme": "non_eu_program", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "attitude_only" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "mack2021:c02": { "citekey": "mack2021", "claim_id": "c02", "title": "The Effect of Administrative Burden on Farmers' Perceptions of Cross-Compliance-Based Direct Payment Policy", "year": 2021, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/puar.13335", "claim": "Greater experienced administrative burden significantly predicted a more negative perception of cross-compliance direct-payment policy.", "page": 5, "quote_start": "Overall, regression results verify", "quote_end": "Thus, H1 cannot be rejected.", "caveat": "object_mismatch", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Mack et al., 2021", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Mack", "Ritzel", "Heitkämper", "El Benni" ], "context": { "geography": "other_eu_ch_uk", "system": "multi", "scheme": "conditionality", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "attitude_only" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "mapa2025:c05": { "citekey": "mapa2025", "claim_id": "c05", "title": "La campaña PAC 2025 registra más de 582.000 solicitudes y 22 millones de hectáreas declaradas en toda España", "year": 2025, "url": "", "claim": "The ministry presents eco-schemes as the main novelty of CAP 2023-2027, remunerating voluntary environmental practices, with consolidated good reception.", "page": 2, "quote_start": "Los datos evidencian la consolidación", "quote_end": "en favor del medio ambiente.", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "MAPA, 2025", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "MAPA" ], "context": { "geography": "spain", "system": "multi", "scheme": "eco_scheme", "evidence": "statistics", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "massfeller2022:c04": { "citekey": "massfeller2022", "claim_id": "c04", "title": "Farmers’ acceptance of results-based agri-environmental schemes: A German perspective", "year": 2022, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2022.106281", "claim": "A one-unit increase in injunctive norms may be associated with approximately 99% more arable land intended for enrolment among willing participants.", "page": 7, "quote_start": "For the second step, participation intensity", "quote_end": "approximately 99 %.", "caveat": "outcome_type", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Massfeller et al., 2022", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Massfeller", "Meraner", "Hüttel", "Uehleke" ], "context": { "geography": "other_eu_ch_uk", "system": "arable", "scheme": "aes_results", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "intention" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "massfeller2022:c05": { "citekey": "massfeller2022", "claim_id": "c05", "title": "Farmers’ acceptance of results-based agri-environmental schemes: A German perspective", "year": 2022, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2022.106281", "claim": "Cognitive factors may shape entry into the scheme, while social factors appear more closely related to intended participation intensity.", "page": 8, "quote_start": "Overall, these findings lend support", "quote_end": "clearly related to social factors.", "caveat": "outcome_type", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Massfeller et al., 2022", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Massfeller", "Meraner", "Hüttel", "Uehleke" ], "context": { "geography": "other_eu_ch_uk", "system": "arable", "scheme": "aes_results", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "intention" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "massfeller2022:c08": { "citekey": "massfeller2022", "claim_id": "c08", "title": "Farmers’ acceptance of results-based agri-environmental schemes: A German perspective", "year": 2022, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2022.106281", "claim": "The younger, better-educated and more AES-experienced convenience sample may have biased stated scheme acceptance upward.", "page": 9, "quote_start": "Second, we rely on a convenience sample", "quote_end": "might have distorted scheme acceptance upwards.", "caveat": "outcome_type", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Massfeller et al., 2022", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Massfeller", "Meraner", "Hüttel", "Uehleke" ], "context": { "geography": "other_eu_ch_uk", "system": "arable", "scheme": "aes_results", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "intention" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "moralesjerrett2020:c01": { "citekey": "moralesjerrett2020", "claim_id": "c01", "title": "The Contribution of Traditional Meat Goat Farming Systems to Human Wellbeing and Its Importance for the Sustainability of This Livestock Subsector", "year": 2020, "url": "https://doi.org/10.3390/su12031181", "claim": "Irregularity and delays in receiving aid scored 2.67 of 3 as a limiting factor for Andalusian meat goat farming.", "page": 11, "quote_start": null, "quote_end": null, "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Morales-Jerrett et al., 2020", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Morales-Jerrett", "Mancilla-Leytón", "Delgado-Pertíñez", "Mena" ], "context": { "geography": "andalusia", "system": "livestock", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "mixed", "outcome": "economic" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "munozulecia2025:c04": { "citekey": "munozulecia2025", "claim_id": "c04", "title": "Fighting the pollinators decline in practice – Farmers’ willingness to accept an eco-scheme for their conservation in Aragon, Spain", "year": 2025, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resenv.2025.100208", "claim": "Greater environmental concern was positively related to choosing the most demanding land allocations and every pesticide-reduction level.", "page": 6, "quote_start": "Regarding the interaction between farmers’ environmental concerns", "quote_end": "permanent crops sample (Tables 6 and 7).", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Muñoz-Ulecia et al., 2025", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Muñoz-Ulecia", "Uldemolins", "Bernués", "de-Magistris", "Villamayor-Tomás", "Martín-Collado" ], "context": { "geography": "spain", "system": "mixed", "scheme": "eco_scheme", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "wta_wtp_stated" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "niskanen2021:c09": { "citekey": "niskanen2021", "claim_id": "c09", "title": "Farmers' heterogeneous preferences towards results-based environmental policies", "year": 2021, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2020.105227", "claim": "The internet survey yielded 591 usable responses at 13% (crop) and 11% (livestock) response rates.", "page": 2, "quote_start": "The questionnaire produced 591 usable responses", "quote_end": "for animal husbandry farmers.", "caveat": "none", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Niskanen et al., 2021", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Niskanen", "Tienhaara", "Haltia", "Pouta" ], "context": { "geography": "other_eu_ch_uk", "system": "mixed", "scheme": "aes_results", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "wta_wtp_stated" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "niskanen2021:c10": { "citekey": "niskanen2021", "claim_id": "c10", "title": "Farmers' heterogeneous preferences towards results-based environmental policies", "year": 2021, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2020.105227", "claim": "Attitude sum-scales with Cronbach's alpha between 0.67 and 0.75 were treated as acceptable for aggregation.", "page": 5, "quote_start": "Alpha scores for the three aggregates", "quote_end": "were acceptable (0.67–0.75).", "caveat": "none", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Niskanen et al., 2021", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Niskanen", "Tienhaara", "Haltia", "Pouta" ], "context": { "geography": "other_eu_ch_uk", "system": "mixed", "scheme": "aes_results", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "wta_wtp_stated" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "ouroagouda2024:c01": { "citekey": "ouroagouda2024", "claim_id": "c01", "title": "Farmers’ Willingness to Participate in Collective Results-based Agri-environment- and-Climate Schemes: A Choice Experiment in Southern Spain", "year": 2024, "url": "", "claim": "The online survey yielded 658 complete questionnaires, an 8% response rate.", "page": 39, "quote_start": "The final sample includes 658", "quote_end": "response rate of 8%).", "caveat": "outcome_type", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Ouro Aghouda, 2024", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Ouro Aghouda" ], "context": { "geography": "andalusia", "system": "olive", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "wta_wtp_stated" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "parra2022:c07": { "citekey": "parra2022", "claim_id": "c07", "title": "Identification of Farmers' Barriers to Implement Sustainable Management Practices in Olive Groves", "year": 2022, "url": "https://doi.org/10.3390/su14116451", "claim": "Omega reliabilities were 0.78, 0.63, 0.68 and 0.59 for the four factors, with a total-score omega of 0.67 described as acceptable.", "page": 8, "quote_start": "The consistency values (Omega McDonald's)", "quote_end": "was acceptable (0.67).", "caveat": "none", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Parra et al., 2022", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Parra", "Garcia-Lopez", "Piqueras", "García" ], "context": { "geography": "spain", "system": "olive", "scheme": "general_practice_adoption", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "attitude_only" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "peer2022:c02": { "citekey": "peer2022", "claim_id": "c02", "title": "How can the European Common Agricultural Policy help halt biodiversity loss? Recommendations by over 300 experts", "year": 2022, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/conl.12901", "claim": "Funding primarily existing practices through eco-schemes risks windfall effects and watered-down environmental ambition.", "page": 6, "quote_start": "There is a considerable risk of watering down", "quote_end": "included under Conditionality.", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Pe'er et al., 2022", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Pe'er", "Finn", "Díaz", "Birkenstock", "Lakner", "Röder", "Kazakova", "Šumrada", "Bezák", "Concepción", "Dänhardt", "Morales", "Rac", "Špulerová", "Schindler", "Stavrinides", "Targetti", "Viaggi", "Vogiatzakis", "Guyomard" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "empirical_qual", "outcome": "other" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "peer2022:c07": { "citekey": "peer2022", "claim_id": "c07", "title": "How can the European Common Agricultural Policy help halt biodiversity loss? Recommendations by over 300 experts", "year": 2022, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/conl.12901", "claim": "Many national eco-scheme options support existing practices with little added value, some merely substituting weak conditionality standards.", "page": 10, "quote_start": "Although some Eco-schemes include options with", "quote_end": "longer-term fallow land).", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Pe'er et al., 2022", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Pe'er", "Finn", "Díaz", "Birkenstock", "Lakner", "Röder", "Kazakova", "Šumrada", "Bezák", "Concepción", "Dänhardt", "Morales", "Rac", "Špulerová", "Schindler", "Stavrinides", "Targetti", "Viaggi", "Vogiatzakis", "Guyomard" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "empirical_qual", "outcome": "other" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "peer2022:c08": { "citekey": "peer2022", "claim_id": "c08", "title": "How can the European Common Agricultural Policy help halt biodiversity loss? Recommendations by over 300 experts", "year": 2022, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/conl.12901", "claim": "Collaborative, coordinated implementation within target areas is recommended to enhance landscape-scale ecological success, with farming-community benefits.", "page": 5, "quote_start": "By extending the spatial scale of interventions,", "quote_end": "(Westerink et al., 2017).", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Pe'er et al., 2022", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Pe'er", "Finn", "Díaz", "Birkenstock", "Lakner", "Röder", "Kazakova", "Šumrada", "Bezák", "Concepción", "Dänhardt", "Morales", "Rac", "Špulerová", "Schindler", "Stavrinides", "Targetti", "Viaggi", "Vogiatzakis", "Guyomard" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "empirical_qual", "outcome": "other" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "penuela2026:c02": { "citekey": "penuela2026", "claim_id": "c02", "title": "Soil erosion in Mediterranean olive groves: a review", "year": 2026, "url": "https://doi.org/10.5194/soil-12-93-2026", "claim": "Bare-soil management is rooted in a cultural identity in which a 'clean' tilled field signals diligence and groundcover signals neglect.", "page": 94, "quote_start": "This practice of maintaining bare soil is deeply rooted in a cultural identity where a", "quote_end": "weed-free field is perceived as signs of diligent farming", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "reviewed_study", "citation_mode": "cite_original_source", "apa_cite": "Sastre et al., 2017, as cited in Peñuela et al., 2026", "citation_review": true, "authors": [ "Peñuela", "González-Sánchez", "Milazzo" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "olive", "scheme": "general_practice_adoption", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "biophysical" }, "attributed_study": "Sastre et al. (2017)", "status": "citation review required" }, "penuela2026:c05": { "citekey": "penuela2026", "claim_id": "c05", "title": "Soil erosion in Mediterranean olive groves: a review", "year": 2026, "url": "https://doi.org/10.5194/soil-12-93-2026", "claim": "Because erosion has not visibly reduced olive yields, farmers have had no direct incentive to adopt conservation practices.", "page": 106, "quote_start": "This absence of a negative impact on", "quote_end": "unsustainable practices to continue.", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Peñuela et al., 2026", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Peñuela", "González-Sánchez", "Milazzo" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "olive", "scheme": "general_practice_adoption", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "biophysical" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "penuela2026:c07": { "citekey": "penuela2026", "claim_id": "c07", "title": "Soil erosion in Mediterranean olive groves: a review", "year": 2026, "url": "https://doi.org/10.5194/soil-12-93-2026", "claim": "Under natural rainfall, conservation practices in olive groves reduced soil loss by 68% and runoff by 34% relative to bare soil.", "page": 102, "quote_start": "RP, which measure erosion under natural", "quote_end": "34 % for runoff.", "caveat": "object_mismatch", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Peñuela et al., 2026", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Peñuela", "González-Sánchez", "Milazzo" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "olive", "scheme": "general_practice_adoption", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "biophysical" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "perezsanchez2024:c02": { "citekey": "perezsanchez2024", "claim_id": "c02", "title": "Unraveling spatial agglomeration patterns in agri-environmental schemes: Evidence from the improvement of steppe habitats in the Natura 2000 network in Catalonia (Spain)", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2024.107145", "claim": "Cooperative members were more likely to participate in the Catalan steppe-habitat AES.", "page": 10, "quote_start": "We also observed that professional", "quote_end": "adopt this AES", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Pérez-Sánchez et al., 2024", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Pérez-Sánchez", "Pierri-Daunt", "Villamayor-Tomas" ], "context": { "geography": "spain", "system": "arable", "scheme": "aes_practice", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "polakova2024:c02": { "citekey": "polakova2024", "claim_id": "c02", "title": "Interpreting Different Narratives about Land Services and Land Use Economics of Common Agricultural Policy", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.3390/land13050620", "claim": "Eco-schemes elaborate on the former greening measures, tailored to different land uses by each member state individually.", "page": 2, "quote_start": "As a result, the current CAP", "quote_end": "each member state individually.", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Poláková et al., 2024", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Poláková", "Humpál", "Svoboda", "Soukup" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "statistics", "outcome": "economic" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "polakova2024:c06": { "citekey": "polakova2024", "claim_id": "c06", "title": "Interpreting Different Narratives about Land Services and Land Use Economics of Common Agricultural Policy", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.3390/land13050620", "claim": "Variability in eco-scheme technical design across member states will be the main obstacle to assessing their effectiveness by 2027.", "page": 14, "quote_start": "The variability of eco-schemes in", "quote_end": "CAP Strategic Plans expire.", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Poláková et al., 2024", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Poláková", "Humpál", "Svoboda", "Soukup" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "statistics", "outcome": "economic" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "ranjan2019:c10": { "citekey": "ranjan2019", "claim_id": "c10", "title": "Synthesizing Conservation Motivations and Barriers: What Have We Learned from Qualitative Studies of Farmers' Behaviors in the United States?", "year": 2019, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1080/08941920.2019.1648710", "claim": "Meeting economic and farm-management needs is necessary but insufficient; social-psychological factors like norms, identity, risk and trust mediate adoption.", "page": 1187, "quote_start": "Our findings show that farmers' economic", "quote_end": "and trustworthiness of information.", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Ranjan et al., 2019", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Ranjan", "Church", "Floress", "Prokopy" ], "context": { "geography": "non_eu", "system": "multi", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "redpac2025:c03": { "citekey": "redpac2025", "claim_id": "c03", "title": "REDR PAC / MAPA, \"Los ecorregímenes en el Plan Estratégico de la PAC español\"", "year": 2025, "url": "", "claim": "In 2023, 19.1M ha were enrolled in eco-schemes; adopters' average farm size (40.9 ha) was over twice that of non-adopters (18.6 ha).", "page": 12, "quote_start": "19.105.887 hectáreas solicitadas para ecorregímenes", "quote_end": "Las explotaciones que solicitan ecorregímenes son de mayor tamaño medio (40,9 ha) frente a las que no los solicitan (18,6 ha)", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "policy_document", "citation_mode": "cite_original_source", "apa_cite": "REDR, None", "citation_review": true, "authors": [ "REDR" ], "context": { "geography": "spain", "system": "multi", "scheme": "eco_scheme", "evidence": "policy_doc", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "citation review required" }, "redpac2025:c04": { "citekey": "redpac2025", "claim_id": "c04", "title": "REDR PAC / MAPA, \"Los ecorregímenes en el Plan Estratégico de la PAC español\"", "year": 2025, "url": "", "claim": "In 2024, 19.2M ha were enrolled (88% of ABRS); 77.5% of applicants enrolled, with rising uptake in arid zones.", "page": 13, "quote_start": "19.200.567 hectáreas solicitadas para ecorregímenes", "quote_end": "sube la acogida en zonas áridas", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "policy_document", "citation_mode": "cite_original_source", "apa_cite": "REDR, None", "citation_review": true, "authors": [ "REDR" ], "context": { "geography": "spain", "system": "multi", "scheme": "eco_scheme", "evidence": "policy_doc", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "citation review required" }, "reg20241468:c02": { "citekey": "reg20241468", "claim_id": "c02", "title": "Regulation (EU) 2024/1468 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 14 May 2024 amending Regulations (EU) 2021/2115 and (EU) 2021/2116 as regards good agricultural and environmental condition standards, schemes for climate, environment and animal welfare, amendment of the CAP Strategic Plans, review of the CAP Strategic Plans and exemptions from controls and penalties", "year": null, "url": "", "claim": "Recital 3 of Regulation (EU) 2024/1468 cites extreme meteorological events (droughts and flooding), the energy/input price shock from Russia's war against Ukraine, the cost [...]", "page": 1, "quote_start": "farmers are facing an exceptional range of difficulties and uncertainties", "quote_end": "as economic actors.", "caveat": "none", "evidence_origin": "policy_document", "citation_mode": "cite_original_source", "apa_cite": "Reg, None", "citation_review": true, "authors": [], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "conditionality", "evidence": "policy_doc", "outcome": "other" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "citation review required" }, "rodriguezsousa2020:c09": { "citekey": "rodriguezsousa2020", "claim_id": "c09", "title": "Evaluation of the Objectives and Concerns of Farmers to Apply Different Agricultural Managements in Olive Groves: The Case of Estepa Region (Southern, Spain)", "year": 2020, "url": "https://doi.org/10.3390/land9100366", "claim": "Authors call for continuous two-way information channels between administrations at all scales and olive farmers on environmental management.", "page": 15, "quote_start": "Different institutions at different scales and with different perspectives", "quote_end": "(bottom-up information) to these institutions.", "caveat": "object_mismatch", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Rodríguez Sousa et al., 2020", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Rodríguez Sousa", "Parra-López", "Sayadi-Gmada", "Barandica", "Rescia" ], "context": { "geography": "andalusia", "system": "olive", "scheme": "general_practice_adoption", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "attitude_only" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "rodriguezsousa2020:c10": { "citekey": "rodriguezsousa2020", "claim_id": "c10", "title": "Evaluation of the Objectives and Concerns of Farmers to Apply Different Agricultural Managements in Olive Groves: The Case of Estepa Region (Southern, Spain)", "year": 2020, "url": "https://doi.org/10.3390/land9100366", "claim": "Farmers' motivations and concerns behind choosing an olive management model remain little investigated compared with biophysical comparisons of models.", "page": 3, "quote_start": "Although there are numerous comparative studies analysing", "quote_end": "remains little investigated.", "caveat": "none", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Rodríguez Sousa et al., 2020", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Rodríguez Sousa", "Parra-López", "Sayadi-Gmada", "Barandica", "Rescia" ], "context": { "geography": "andalusia", "system": "olive", "scheme": "general_practice_adoption", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "attitude_only" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "ruizcatedra2025:c07": { "citekey": "ruizcatedra2025", "claim_id": "c07", "title": "Do management practices which enhance nature-based processes improve soil health in olive groves?", "year": 2025, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.geoderma.2025.117276", "claim": "The authors assert that many olive groves already have moderate to high implementation of nature-based practices.", "page": 9, "quote_start": "The widespread adoption of NBS in olive", "quote_end": "promoting sustainable soil management.", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Ruiz-Cátedra et al., 2025", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Ruiz-Cátedra", "Calero", "Domouso", "García-Ruiz" ], "context": { "geography": "andalusia", "system": "olive", "scheme": "na", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "biophysical" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "sanchezmartinez2020:c09": { "citekey": "sanchezmartinez2020", "claim_id": "c09", "title": "Social Innovation in Rural Areas? The Case of Andalusian Olive Oil Co-Operatives", "year": 2020, "url": "https://doi.org/10.3390/su122310019", "claim": "Authors argue cooperatives are social references inseparable from rural society, so their innovations function as social innovations.", "page": 13, "quote_start": "This territorial conception of cooperatives makes", "quote_end": "seen as a social innovation.", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Sánchez-Martínez et al., 2020", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Sánchez-Martínez", "Rodríguez-Cohard", "Garrido-Almonacid", "Gallego-Simón" ], "context": { "geography": "andalusia", "system": "olive", "scheme": "general_practice_adoption", "evidence": "mixed", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "sander2024:c01": { "citekey": "sander2024", "claim_id": "c01", "title": "Participation in individual and collective agri-environmental schemes: A synthesis using the Theory of Planned Behaviour", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jrurstud.2024.103255", "claim": "Attitudes were central for individual-scheme participation; farming-community subjective norms and trust in policy-making were crucial for collective schemes.", "page": 1, "quote_start": "Our analysis highlights the role of farmer attitudes", "quote_end": "participation in collective schemes.", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "review_synthesis", "citation_mode": "cite_original_source", "apa_cite": "Sander et al., 2024", "citation_review": true, "authors": [ "Sander", "Ghazoul", "Finger", "Schaub" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "arable", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "intention" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "citation review required" }, "sander2024:c04": { "citekey": "sander2024", "claim_id": "c04", "title": "Participation in individual and collective agri-environmental schemes: A synthesis using the Theory of Planned Behaviour", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jrurstud.2024.103255", "claim": "A traditional 'good farmer' identity seems to discourage AES participation across several European regions.", "page": 5, "quote_start": "Overall, the idea of being a", "quote_end": "Burton et al. 2008; Westerink et al. 2020).", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "review_synthesis", "citation_mode": "cite_original_source", "apa_cite": "Sander et al., 2024", "citation_review": true, "authors": [ "Sander", "Ghazoul", "Finger", "Schaub" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "arable", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "intention" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "citation review required" }, "sander2024:c08": { "citekey": "sander2024", "claim_id": "c08", "title": "Participation in individual and collective agri-environmental schemes: A synthesis using the Theory of Planned Behaviour", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jrurstud.2024.103255", "claim": "Distrust of government motives and expertise transfers to the scheme, rooted in negative past experiences and changing legislation.", "page": 9, "quote_start": "Studies have found that farmers distrust the government", "quote_end": "these past negative experiences.", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "review_synthesis", "citation_mode": "cite_original_source", "apa_cite": "Sander et al., 2024", "citation_review": true, "authors": [ "Sander", "Ghazoul", "Finger", "Schaub" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "arable", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "intention" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "citation review required" }, "sander2024:c10": { "citekey": "sander2024", "claim_id": "c10", "title": "Participation in individual and collective agri-environmental schemes: A synthesis using the Theory of Planned Behaviour", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jrurstud.2024.103255", "claim": "The review extends TPB with legitimacy and trust, noting prior trust extensions mainly in consumer-choice studies.", "page": 3, "quote_start": "For this study, we use an extended version", "quote_end": "Giampietri et al. 2018).", "caveat": "none", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Sander et al., 2024", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Sander", "Ghazoul", "Finger", "Schaub" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "arable", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "intention" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "sastre2017:c03": { "citekey": "sastre2017", "claim_id": "c03", "title": "Soil loss in an olive grove in Central Spain under cover crops and tillage treatments, and farmer perceptions", "year": 2016, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/s11368-016-1589-9", "claim": "Olive growers report social disapproval of those who do not till; letting vegetation grow is seen as 'for lazy farmers'.", "page": 8, "quote_start": "Moreover, the growers mention a social disapproval", "quote_end": "is for lazy farmers", "caveat": "object_mismatch", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Sastre et al., 2016", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Sastre", "Barbero-Sierra", "Bienes", "Marques", "García-Díaz" ], "context": { "geography": "spain", "system": "olive", "scheme": "general_practice_adoption", "evidence": "mixed", "outcome": "biophysical" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "schaub2023:c01": { "citekey": "schaub2023", "claim_id": "c01", "title": "The role of behavioural factors and opportunity costs in farmers' participation in voluntary agri-environmental schemes: A systematic review", "year": 2023, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1477-9552.12538", "claim": "Stronger farm-related environmental attitudes were insignificantly (52%) or positively (48%) associated with AES participation, never negatively.", "page": 632, "quote_start": "When dealing with voluntary AESs, stronger environmental", "quote_end": "associated with farmers' participation.", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "review_synthesis", "citation_mode": "cite_original_source", "apa_cite": "Schaub et al., 2023", "citation_review": true, "authors": [ "Schaub", "Ghazoul", "Huber", "Zhang", "Sander", "Rees", "Banerjee", "Finger" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "arable", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "citation review required" }, "schaub2023:c02": { "citekey": "schaub2023", "claim_id": "c02", "title": "The role of behavioural factors and opportunity costs in farmers' participation in voluntary agri-environmental schemes: A systematic review", "year": 2023, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1477-9552.12538", "claim": "A positive attitude towards AES was positively linked to participation in 68% of cases, insignificant in 28% and negative in 4%.", "page": 632, "quote_start": "Farmers' positive attitude towards AESs (and", "quote_end": "linked (Table 3).", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "review_synthesis", "citation_mode": "cite_original_source", "apa_cite": "Schaub et al., 2023", "citation_review": true, "authors": [ "Schaub", "Ghazoul", "Huber", "Zhang", "Sander", "Rees", "Banerjee", "Finger" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "arable", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "citation review required" }, "schaub2023:c04": { "citekey": "schaub2023", "claim_id": "c04", "title": "The role of behavioural factors and opportunity costs in farmers' participation in voluntary agri-environmental schemes: A systematic review", "year": 2023, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1477-9552.12538", "claim": "Institutional and state trust related positively or not at all to AES participation; generalised trust in people was never significant.", "page": 631, "quote_start": "Trust in institutions and the state was connected", "quote_end": "has not been found significant.", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "review_synthesis", "citation_mode": "cite_original_source", "apa_cite": "Schaub et al., 2023", "citation_review": true, "authors": [ "Schaub", "Ghazoul", "Huber", "Zhang", "Sander", "Rees", "Banerjee", "Finger" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "arable", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "citation review required" }, "schaub2023:c08": { "citekey": "schaub2023", "claim_id": "c08", "title": "The role of behavioural factors and opportunity costs in farmers' participation in voluntary agri-environmental schemes: A systematic review", "year": 2023, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1477-9552.12538", "claim": "Perceived behavioural control and perceived scheme stability were positively or not related to AES participation.", "page": 634, "quote_start": "The most studied cognitive factors not discussed", "quote_end": "participation in AESs (Table 4).", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "review_synthesis", "citation_mode": "cite_original_source", "apa_cite": "Schaub et al., 2023", "citation_review": true, "authors": [ "Schaub", "Ghazoul", "Huber", "Zhang", "Sander", "Rees", "Banerjee", "Finger" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "arable", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "citation review required" }, "schaub2023:c11": { "citekey": "schaub2023", "claim_id": "c11", "title": "The role of behavioural factors and opportunity costs in farmers' participation in voluntary agri-environmental schemes: A systematic review", "year": 2023, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1477-9552.12538", "claim": "AES participation studies are concentrated in the United States, Germany and France.", "page": 625, "quote_start": "The countries with the highest number of studies", "quote_end": "France (Figure S1).", "caveat": "none", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Schaub et al., 2023", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Schaub", "Ghazoul", "Huber", "Zhang", "Sander", "Rees", "Banerjee", "Finger" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "arable", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "schaub2023:c12": { "citekey": "schaub2023", "claim_id": "c12", "title": "The role of behavioural factors and opportunity costs in farmers' participation in voluntary agri-environmental schemes: A systematic review", "year": 2023, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1477-9552.12538", "claim": "A more favourable business attitude was never significantly associated with AES participation in the eight studies measuring it.", "page": 632, "quote_start": "A more favourable business attitude was never", "quote_end": "including this factor.", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "review_synthesis", "citation_mode": "cite_original_source", "apa_cite": "Schaub et al., 2023", "citation_review": true, "authors": [ "Schaub", "Ghazoul", "Huber", "Zhang", "Sander", "Rees", "Banerjee", "Finger" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "arable", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "citation review required" }, "schulte2020:c02": { "citekey": "schulte2020", "claim_id": "c02", "title": "Social identity as a key concept for connecting transformative societal change with individual environmental activism", "year": 2020, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvp.2020.101525", "claim": "Pro-environmental opinion-group identity was more strongly associated with collective-action intentions or self-reported behaviour than corresponding private-sphere measures.", "page": 1, "quote_start": "The third meta-analysis supports that", "quote_end": "eight samples", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "review_synthesis", "citation_mode": "cite_original_source", "apa_cite": "Schulte et al., 2020, as cited in Schulte et al., 2020", "citation_review": true, "authors": [ "Schulte", "Bamberg", "Rees", "Rollin" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "na", "scheme": "na", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "intention" }, "attributed_study": "Schulte et al. (2020)", "status": "citation review required" }, "schulze2024:c06": { "citekey": "schulze2024", "claim_id": "c06", "title": "Using farmers' ex ante preferences to design agri-environmental contracts: A systematic review", "year": 2023, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1477-9552.12570", "claim": "Discrete-choice evidence should be triangulated with revealed-preference experiments and qualitative research before policy decisions.", "page": 32, "quote_start": "Although DCEs can be useful for policy design", "quote_end": "This triangulation of methods helps balance the strengths and weaknesses of each approach (Colen et al., 2016).", "caveat": "outcome_type", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Schulze et al., 2023", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Schulze", "Zagórska", "Häfner", "Markiewicz", "Czajkowski", "Matzdorf" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "wta_wtp_stated" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "sok2021:c01": { "citekey": "sok2021", "claim_id": "c01", "title": "Farmer Behaviour as Reasoned Action: A Critical Review of Research with the Theory of Planned Behaviour", "year": 2020, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1477-9552.12408", "claim": "The reviewed theory suggests intention is the most immediate antecedent and best predictor of actual behaviour.", "page": 390, "quote_start": "They suggested that, instead of broad attitudes", "quote_end": "actual behavioural performance.", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "theoretical_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Sok et al., 2020", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Sok", "Borges", "Schmidt", "Ajzen" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "sok2021:c02": { "citekey": "sok2021", "claim_id": "c02", "title": "Farmer Behaviour as Reasoned Action: A Critical Review of Research with the Theory of Planned Behaviour", "year": 2020, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1477-9552.12408", "claim": "Perceived behavioural control affects intention and can help predict behaviour insofar as it accurately reflects actual control.", "page": 391, "quote_start": "Perceived behavioural control, defined as people’s perceptions", "quote_end": "predict and explain behaviour.", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "theoretical_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Sok et al., 2020", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Sok", "Borges", "Schmidt", "Ajzen" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "sok2021:c03": { "citekey": "sok2021", "claim_id": "c03", "title": "Farmer Behaviour as Reasoned Action: A Critical Review of Research with the Theory of Planned Behaviour", "year": 2020, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1477-9552.12408", "claim": "Perceived behavioural control comprises capacity to perform and autonomy over whether performance is up to the actor.", "page": 392, "quote_start": "Similarly, perceived behavioural control is found to contain two sub-dimensions", "quote_end": "performance of the behaviour is or is not completely up to them.", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "theoretical_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Sok et al., 2020", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Sok", "Borges", "Schmidt", "Ajzen" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "sok2021:c04": { "citekey": "sok2021", "claim_id": "c04", "title": "Farmer Behaviour as Reasoned Action: A Critical Review of Research with the Theory of Planned Behaviour", "year": 2020, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1477-9552.12408", "claim": "Subjective norm includes injunctive expectations and descriptive perceptions of what important others actually do.", "page": 392, "quote_start": "The former refers to people’s perception", "quote_end": "what important others themselves do.", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "theoretical_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Sok et al., 2020", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Sok", "Borges", "Schmidt", "Ajzen" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "sok2021:c05": { "citekey": "sok2021", "claim_id": "c05", "title": "Farmer Behaviour as Reasoned Action: A Critical Review of Research with the Theory of Planned Behaviour", "year": 2020, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1477-9552.12408", "claim": "TPB constructs should share a behavioral target, action, context and time period.", "page": 392, "quote_start": "In research with the TPB it is important to clearly define", "quote_end": "same TACT elements (construct compatibility).", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "theoretical_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Sok et al., 2020", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Sok", "Borges", "Schmidt", "Ajzen" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "sok2021:c06": { "citekey": "sok2021", "claim_id": "c06", "title": "Farmer Behaviour as Reasoned Action: A Critical Review of Research with the Theory of Planned Behaviour", "year": 2020, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1477-9552.12408", "claim": "Compatible measures explained 57% of intention variance on average versus 40% for incompatible measures; the difference was significant.", "page": 400, "quote_start": "The boxplots in Figure 4 shows the effect of compatibility", "quote_end": "p = .003.", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "review_synthesis", "citation_mode": "cite_original_source", "apa_cite": "Sok et al., 2020", "citation_review": true, "authors": [ "Sok", "Borges", "Schmidt", "Ajzen" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "citation review required" }, "sok2021:c07": { "citekey": "sok2021", "claim_id": "c07", "title": "Farmer Behaviour as Reasoned Action: A Critical Review of Research with the Theory of Planned Behaviour", "year": 2020, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1477-9552.12408", "claim": "Both Pillar 1 eco-schemes and Pillar 2 agri-environment-climate measures depend on voluntary participation by farmers.", "page": 389, "quote_start": "Both the newly announced", "quote_end": "by farmers (European Commission, 2019).", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "policy_document", "citation_mode": "cite_original_source", "apa_cite": "European Commission, 2019, as cited in Sok et al., 2020", "citation_review": true, "authors": [ "Sok", "Borges", "Schmidt", "Ajzen" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": "European Commission (2019)", "status": "citation review required" }, "sok2021:c09": { "citekey": "sok2021", "claim_id": "c09", "title": "Farmer Behaviour as Reasoned Action: A Critical Review of Research with the Theory of Planned Behaviour", "year": 2020, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1477-9552.12408", "claim": "Of 124 TPB applications to farmer behaviour, 40% concerned crop management, including participation in agri-environmental schemes.", "page": 396, "quote_start": "Of the 124 articles, 40% assessed farmer behaviour in a crop management context", "quote_end": "participating in environmental schemes", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Sok et al., 2020", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Sok", "Borges", "Schmidt", "Ajzen" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "sok2021:c10": { "citekey": "sok2021", "claim_id": "c10", "title": "Farmer Behaviour as Reasoned Action: A Critical Review of Research with the Theory of Planned Behaviour", "year": 2020, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1477-9552.12408", "claim": "Only a third of applicable TPB farmer studies fully met the compatibility principle and about half used a pilot study.", "page": 398, "quote_start": "The data presented in Table 2", "quote_end": "conducted a pilot study.", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Sok et al., 2020", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Sok", "Borges", "Schmidt", "Ajzen" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "multi", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "review_systematic", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "tama2021:c04": { "citekey": "tama2021", "claim_id": "c04", "title": "Assessing farmers’ intention towards conservation agriculture by using the Extended Theory of Planned Behavior", "year": 2021, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2020.111654", "claim": "The study measured conservation-agriculture intention rather than actual farmer behaviour.", "page": 8, "quote_start": "This study assessed intention towards", "quote_end": "behavior of a farmer", "caveat": "outcome_type", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Tama et al., 2021", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Tama", "Ying", "Yu", "Hoque", "Adnan", "Sarker" ], "context": { "geography": "non_eu", "system": "arable", "scheme": "general_practice_adoption", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "intention" }, "attributed_study": "Tama et al. (2021)", "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "thapa2024:c01": { "citekey": "thapa2024", "claim_id": "c01", "title": "thapa2024", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2024.107163", "claim": "In a full TPB structural equation model of intent to enrol, subjective norms carry the largest standardised path, ahead of perceived behavioural control and attitude.", "page": 5, "quote_start": "The model with standardized results", "quote_end": "followed by attitudes (β = 0.12, p< 0.000).", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Thapa et al., 2024", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Thapa", "Chapagain", "McMurry", "Smith", "Joshi" ], "context": { "geography": "non_eu", "system": "arable", "scheme": "non_eu_program", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "intention" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "thapa2024:c02": { "citekey": "thapa2024", "claim_id": "c02", "title": "thapa2024", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2024.107163", "claim": "All three socio-psychological TPB measures reach significance against enrolment intention in the same model.", "page": 5, "quote_start": "In the structural model, the regression", "quote_end": "intention to enroll in CRP in the future.", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Thapa et al., 2024", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Thapa", "Chapagain", "McMurry", "Smith", "Joshi" ], "context": { "geography": "non_eu", "system": "arable", "scheme": "non_eu_program", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "intention" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "thapa2024:c05": { "citekey": "thapa2024", "claim_id": "c05", "title": "thapa2024", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2024.107163", "claim": "The structural model reports RMSEA of 0.08 and CFI of 0.917 as evidence of acceptable fit.", "page": 5, "quote_start": "Our structural model fits the data well", "quote_end": "(Hu and Bentler, 1999; Nachtigall et al., 2003).", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Thapa et al., 2024", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Thapa", "Chapagain", "McMurry", "Smith", "Joshi" ], "context": { "geography": "non_eu", "system": "arable", "scheme": "non_eu_program", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "intention" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "thapa2024:c07": { "citekey": "thapa2024", "claim_id": "c07", "title": "thapa2024", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2024.107163", "claim": "The study applies the theory of planned behaviour by structural equation modelling to voluntary enrolment in an agri-environmental payment programme.", "page": 1, "quote_start": "Following the underpinnings of the Theory", "quote_end": "intent to enroll in CRP.", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Thapa et al., 2024", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Thapa", "Chapagain", "McMurry", "Smith", "Joshi" ], "context": { "geography": "non_eu", "system": "arable", "scheme": "non_eu_program", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "intention" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "thapa2024:c11": { "citekey": "thapa2024", "claim_id": "c11", "title": "thapa2024", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2024.107163", "claim": "Programme design and incentives should express the ecosystem value of the target outcome and address financial and non-financial motivations together.", "page": 6, "quote_start": "CRP design and incentives should represent", "quote_end": "factors that influence their future behavior.", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Thapa et al., 2024", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Thapa", "Chapagain", "McMurry", "Smith", "Joshi" ], "context": { "geography": "non_eu", "system": "arable", "scheme": "non_eu_program", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "intention" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "topp2024:c01": { "citekey": "topp2024", "claim_id": "c01", "title": "Mediterranean farmers' understandings of 'good soil management' and 'good farmer' identity in the context of conservation agriculture", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1080/14735903.2024.2335083", "claim": "Productivity and experience/knowledge were the most prominent good-farmer concepts for both conservation-agriculture and conventional-tillage farmers.", "page": 14, "quote_start": "Concerning the second objective of revealing", "quote_end": "their adopted tillage practices.", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Topp et al., 2024", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Topp", "Stephan", "Varela", "Cicek", "Plieninger" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "arable", "scheme": "general_practice_adoption", "evidence": "mixed", "outcome": "attitude_only" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "topp2024:c07": { "citekey": "topp2024", "claim_id": "c07", "title": "Mediterranean farmers' understandings of 'good soil management' and 'good farmer' identity in the context of conservation agriculture", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1080/14735903.2024.2335083", "claim": "Targeted sampling through extension networks and project contacts means the sample does not represent the wider farming population.", "page": 16, "quote_start": "Our targeted sampling of farmers means", "quote_end": "other agricultural communities.", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Topp et al., 2024", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Topp", "Stephan", "Varela", "Cicek", "Plieninger" ], "context": { "geography": "multi", "system": "arable", "scheme": "general_practice_adoption", "evidence": "mixed", "outcome": "attitude_only" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "vainio2021:c01": { "citekey": "vainio2021", "claim_id": "c01", "title": "The legitimacy of result-oriented and action-oriented agri-environmental schemes: A comparison of farmers' and citizens' perceptions", "year": 2021, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2019.104358", "claim": "Citizens perceived the proposed result-oriented AES as more legitimate, whereas farmers attributed greater legitimacy to the current action-oriented AES.", "page": 1, "quote_start": "The results demonstrated that Finnish citizens", "quote_end": "the current action-oriented AES.", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Vainio et al., 2021", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Vainio", "Tienhaara", "Haltia", "Hyvönen", "Pyysiäinen", "Pouta" ], "context": { "geography": "other_eu_ch_uk", "system": "mixed", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "attitude_only" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "vainio2021:c08": { "citekey": "vainio2021", "claim_id": "c08", "title": "The legitimacy of result-oriented and action-oriented agri-environmental schemes: A comparison of farmers' and citizens' perceptions", "year": 2021, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2019.104358", "claim": "The cross-sectional survey design precludes causal inference between legitimacy perceptions and their correlates.", "page": 7, "quote_start": "The survey was cross-sectional, and therefore", "quote_end": "the variables cannot be made.", "caveat": "none", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Vainio et al., 2021", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Vainio", "Tienhaara", "Haltia", "Hyvönen", "Pyysiäinen", "Pouta" ], "context": { "geography": "other_eu_ch_uk", "system": "mixed", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "attitude_only" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "vainio2021:c11": { "citekey": "vainio2021", "claim_id": "c11", "title": "The legitimacy of result-oriented and action-oriented agri-environmental schemes: A comparison of farmers' and citizens' perceptions", "year": 2021, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2019.104358", "claim": "Among both farmers and citizens, preference for the action-oriented AES was associated with perceiving agriculture as already successful in producing ecosystem services.", "page": 7, "quote_start": "Among both groups, a preference for action-oriented", "quote_end": "had been successful in producing ecosystem services.", "caveat": "transfer", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Vainio et al., 2021", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Vainio", "Tienhaara", "Haltia", "Hyvönen", "Pyysiäinen", "Pouta" ], "context": { "geography": "other_eu_ch_uk", "system": "mixed", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "attitude_only" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "villanueva2024:c01": { "citekey": "villanueva2024", "claim_id": "c01", "title": "Comparing practice- and results-based agri-environmental schemes controlled by remote sensing: An application to olive groves in Spain", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1477-9552.12573", "claim": "In the choice tasks, 62% of Andalusian sloping-olive farmers chose practice-based schemes versus 53% for results-based schemes, a significant difference.", "page": 534, "quote_start": "Respondents' choices indicate that 62%", "quote_end": "participation levels being statistically significantly", "caveat": "outcome_type", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Villanueva et al., 2024", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Villanueva", "Granado‐Díaz", "Colombo" ], "context": { "geography": "andalusia", "system": "olive", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "wta_wtp_stated" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "villanueva2024:c06": { "citekey": "villanueva2024", "claim_id": "c06", "title": "Comparing practice- and results-based agri-environmental schemes controlled by remote sensing: An application to olive groves in Spain", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1477-9552.12573", "claim": "Authors argue remote-sensing monitoring requires trust and recommend online support systems and genuine collaboration between farmers and the implementing agency.", "page": 542, "quote_start": "Clearly, the shift to a remote", "quote_end": "between the two parties.", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Villanueva et al., 2024", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Villanueva", "Granado‐Díaz", "Colombo" ], "context": { "geography": "andalusia", "system": "olive", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "wta_wtp_stated" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "villanueva2024:c07": { "citekey": "villanueva2024", "claim_id": "c07", "title": "Comparing practice- and results-based agri-environmental schemes controlled by remote sensing: An application to olive groves in Spain", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1477-9552.12573", "claim": "Protest respondents among Andalusian olive growers cited rejection of any subsidy and lack of trust in public implementing agencies as main reasons.", "page": 533, "quote_start": "The main reasons respondents gave for", "quote_end": "the public implementing agencies.", "caveat": "none", "evidence_origin": "own_data", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Villanueva et al., 2024", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Villanueva", "Granado‐Díaz", "Colombo" ], "context": { "geography": "andalusia", "system": "olive", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "wta_wtp_stated" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "villanueva2024:c08": { "citekey": "villanueva2024", "claim_id": "c08", "title": "Comparing practice- and results-based agri-environmental schemes controlled by remote sensing: An application to olive groves in Spain", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1477-9552.12573", "claim": "Authors propose that results-based requirements could be reduced when external causes such as adverse climatic conditions make outcomes unattainable.", "page": 540, "quote_start": "The application could also be used", "quote_end": "achieve the expected results.", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Villanueva et al., 2024", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Villanueva", "Granado‐Díaz", "Colombo" ], "context": { "geography": "andalusia", "system": "olive", "scheme": "multi", "evidence": "empirical_quant", "outcome": "wta_wtp_stated" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" }, "zielinski2025:c07": { "citekey": "zielinski2025", "claim_id": "c07", "title": "Development of Eco-Schemes as an Important Environmental Measure in Areas Facing Natural or Other Specific Constraints Under the Common Agriculture Policy 2023–2027: Evidence from Poland", "year": 2025, "url": "https://doi.org/10.3390/su17062781", "claim": "Authors assume the most chosen Polish eco-scheme practices were already long in use, so payments may largely reward pre-existing behaviour.", "page": 13, "quote_start": "It is reasonable to assume that these practices", "quote_end": "nutrients in the soil).", "caveat": "evidence_type", "evidence_origin": "authors_argument", "citation_mode": "cite_this_paper", "apa_cite": "Zieliński et al., 2025", "citation_review": false, "authors": [ "Zieliński", "Józwiak", "Żak", "Rokicki" ], "context": { "geography": "other_eu_ch_uk", "system": "multi", "scheme": "eco_scheme", "evidence": "statistics", "outcome": "behaviour" }, "attributed_study": null, "status": "extracted; not independently certified" } }